Continue here
Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
-
- Master Gossiper
- Posts: 3702
- Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 4:32 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
Classic PLL! Aria looks the most guilty followed by Hanna. Spencer and Emily are serving MAJOR attitude!!VeronicaSawyer wrote:Continue here
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
^^^I've always thought that, based on the starting, Aria is A/guilty of something because she does the shhh. Who knows, though, they may have just wanted lucy hale and her big eyes to do it because it looked good, lol
- CoralCat
- Gossiper
- Posts: 698
- Joined: Fri May 16, 2014 9:47 am
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
I think Melissa makes the confession video because she's either going to commit suicide or knows she'll be murdered for telling, I think she was on the A team because she knew something others didn't and was protecting herself and her family
I saw a good theory on Tumblr:
Season 5, Episode 10 “A Dark Ali”
"Emily BLOWS up on Alison, when Alison says she wasn’t there when she ID’ed Cyrus, implying that she wouldn’t understand…To which Emily replies:
"When? When wasn’t I there? When Hanna broke her leg because of -A?
When I almost died in an elevator because I was trying to find out who killed you?
When Spencer checked into Radley because everything your disappearance put us through?”
We know that -A was behind those things that happened to Hanna, Spencer, and Emily but why didn’t Emily mention what happened to Aria on the A-Train? Is it possible the writers didn’t add that to Emily’s little outburst because it had nothing to do with the work of -A?
We know that Wilden was involved in putting Aria in the box and attempting to push her to her death, and Melissa was supposedly the other culprit. Wilden is obviously not -A, and I’ve said it before I do not think that Melissa is either. I still believe that Melissa has been trying to protect Spencer, so I don’t think that she is -A either. Melissa has asked Spencer to leave Rosewood with her for their own safety not once but twice. I still think it is very possible that they may have been trying to get rid of Aria because she is guilty of something big, is -A, or is working with -A.
People have said that -A has never done anything really bad to Aria unlike the rest of the liars, and if what happened to her on the A-Train wasn’t -A’s doing than that would be true. Most of the things that have happened to Aria have ultimately helped her. -A once saved her relationship, tested Zach so her mom didn’t end up marrying a scum bag, told Ella about Byron’s affair, which spared Aria from having to be the one to tell her… Overall the other liars have seemed to suffer more at the hands of -A. So maybe, this is a little clue by the writers that Aria’s near death experience was not orchestrated by -A. I just don’t see why they would choose to leave that out especially considering it could be considered worse than Hanna breaking her leg?
Why did the writers not include Aria’s experience in Emily’s speech when she was trying so hard to make Alison feel guilty for the mess she has made of their lives?
Maybe, just maybe, because -A had nothing to do with it?"
I saw a good theory on Tumblr:
Season 5, Episode 10 “A Dark Ali”
"Emily BLOWS up on Alison, when Alison says she wasn’t there when she ID’ed Cyrus, implying that she wouldn’t understand…To which Emily replies:
"When? When wasn’t I there? When Hanna broke her leg because of -A?
When I almost died in an elevator because I was trying to find out who killed you?
When Spencer checked into Radley because everything your disappearance put us through?”
We know that -A was behind those things that happened to Hanna, Spencer, and Emily but why didn’t Emily mention what happened to Aria on the A-Train? Is it possible the writers didn’t add that to Emily’s little outburst because it had nothing to do with the work of -A?
We know that Wilden was involved in putting Aria in the box and attempting to push her to her death, and Melissa was supposedly the other culprit. Wilden is obviously not -A, and I’ve said it before I do not think that Melissa is either. I still believe that Melissa has been trying to protect Spencer, so I don’t think that she is -A either. Melissa has asked Spencer to leave Rosewood with her for their own safety not once but twice. I still think it is very possible that they may have been trying to get rid of Aria because she is guilty of something big, is -A, or is working with -A.
People have said that -A has never done anything really bad to Aria unlike the rest of the liars, and if what happened to her on the A-Train wasn’t -A’s doing than that would be true. Most of the things that have happened to Aria have ultimately helped her. -A once saved her relationship, tested Zach so her mom didn’t end up marrying a scum bag, told Ella about Byron’s affair, which spared Aria from having to be the one to tell her… Overall the other liars have seemed to suffer more at the hands of -A. So maybe, this is a little clue by the writers that Aria’s near death experience was not orchestrated by -A. I just don’t see why they would choose to leave that out especially considering it could be considered worse than Hanna breaking her leg?
Why did the writers not include Aria’s experience in Emily’s speech when she was trying so hard to make Alison feel guilty for the mess she has made of their lives?
Maybe, just maybe, because -A had nothing to do with it?"
-
- Master Gossiper
- Posts: 3702
- Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 4:32 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
Well, I haven't been able to see the whole episode yet because my internet was crap tonight and I was watching a livestream. BUT, I did see Melissa's secret and I couldn't be more confused. IS Melissa lying, or is Ali lying? And, who else is lying? It's obviously more than coincidental that Bethany would be wearing the same clothes as Ali, be hit in the head like Ali, and be buried alive like Ali. Just none of this makes any sense. They better do some explaining ASAP!
Also can a mod lock the other thread?
Also can a mod lock the other thread?
- JillyBean08
- Learner
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Wed Jun 26, 2013 12:42 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
Haven't finished the episode yet, but was that quote about people only telling you things when they feel like it and only telling you enough to make you want to know more a big fuck you to the viewers from the writers or what? Lol
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
Finished the epi. That was some bullshit. Hate Tanner. Hate Paige. Please keep her off the show. Really feeling like Ali is A but that's probably just another ploy to mislead the viewer.
Also, why do they have to bring in all this supernatural bullshit? I don't care about what happened to Caleb in Ravenswood. Crossing that world with the world of Rosewood (which seemed to at least be rooted in reality/the laws of physics) is a huge mistake. It makes anything and everything possible, and therefore any theorizing or answers totally useless. It could be that a real person killed Bethany or it could just be some random fucking ghost or time traveler! Lol. Maybe they will have a ouija board Halloween episode where they ~contact~ Bethany's ghost
I wonder who will die. Hope it's not Caleb.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Also, why do they have to bring in all this supernatural bullshit? I don't care about what happened to Caleb in Ravenswood. Crossing that world with the world of Rosewood (which seemed to at least be rooted in reality/the laws of physics) is a huge mistake. It makes anything and everything possible, and therefore any theorizing or answers totally useless. It could be that a real person killed Bethany or it could just be some random fucking ghost or time traveler! Lol. Maybe they will have a ouija board Halloween episode where they ~contact~ Bethany's ghost
I wonder who will die. Hope it's not Caleb.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- go_further
- Informer
- Posts: 447
- Joined: Thu Dec 19, 2013 9:24 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
Tonights episode was complete shit. I thought Ali was going to be attached to the lie detector in this episode?? Why would they play the trailer for the finale , after last week's episode??? ugh. No answers at all. Melissas story didn't seem sincere at all. I think she was told by "A" to do it...... And the whole Spencer standing behind the camera made me think what if she is psycho and was actually standing there and remembered it? Like she forced Melissa to confess so she can have the tape?? And her dad knows she is crazy so took Melissa away so Spencer won't hurt her lol... I just never liked Spencer as an actress so I'm bias.
Anyway, the whole Mona thing was weird also. And caleb with the ghost BS. Ravenswood was horrible, don't ever bring it up kbyethanks lol
Anyway, the whole Mona thing was weird also. And caleb with the ghost BS. Ravenswood was horrible, don't ever bring it up kbyethanks lol
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
obviously they're being sponsored by that movie which just ruins everything. for all we know A could be a freaking ghost . they're probably going to have the girls talk to Bethany through the ouija board and she's going to tell the truth of what ~really~ happened
-
- Debater
- Posts: 193
- Joined: Fri May 17, 2013 2:12 am
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
Uh that episode! What was the deal with the supernatural element to it?! I have a feeling Spencer is going to be the one arrested! Also I can't stand Tanner.
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
The girl who gets arrested is wearing a watch! The only one of the girls who wears one is Spencer..GuruSayWhat wrote:Uh that episode! What was the deal with the supernatural element to it?! I have a feeling Spencer is going to be the one arrested! Also I can't stand Tanner.
- JillyBean08
- Learner
- Posts: 89
- Joined: Wed Jun 26, 2013 12:42 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
For some reason I'm expecting Aria's brother to be the one who ends up dead. It was left off that he still wasn't back from dropping Mona off or something. He's an expendable character, but it would be devastating to many of the characters- Aria & Mona especially.
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
If they start killing off siblings as a plot device that would be pretty fucked up. I'm hoping it's someone minor like Sydney, maybe. If it were Paige or Tanner I would be psyched. They need to go
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
- Gossiper
- Posts: 834
- Joined: Sat Jan 19, 2013 5:03 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
- this is a pretty good theory for who dies.
- CoralCat
- Gossiper
- Posts: 698
- Joined: Fri May 16, 2014 9:47 am
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
I don't think Mona dies, plus apparently there's a scene with her in the premiere for 5B but who knows. I personally think it's Melissa but I really hope it Paige-I don't really know what it is precisely but something about her just really annoys me
-
- Master Gossiper
- Posts: 3702
- Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 4:32 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
After this last episode, I'm really mad at the writers. Up until this point I've been okay with them going in circles and stretching out finding who A is, because I know it's such a popular show it shuts down twitter every week so there's no way the show's ending anytime soon. But, I actually thought they were going to give us some answers with Melissa's secret. Instead, I'm more confused than ever. I honestly don't know whether to believe her or not. Was she forced to say that by A or Ali or is it the truth because it makes no sense. She sees Spencer with a shovel so she assumes she hit her, but didn't actually check to make sure it was Ali, and buries the girl....WHAT? So was Ali's whole story about being buried alive a complete lie? She was never hit with a rock, her mom never buried her? Nothing makes sense. Was the whole story with Mrs. D burying Ali alive made up, or was it real so that Ali could fake her death. Why were Ali and Bethany wearing the exact same clothes? Clearly it was a setup, but why would somebody setup Bethany to die in Ali's place instead of Ali just faking her death? The writers should really throw us a bone and stop making stuff up. We watch the show and follow the clues, try to come up with theories, and just when you think you've got some things figured out, you realize nothing is figured out. Nothing we know up to this point means anything. I know Ali made up a bunch of stuff in the season 4 finale, but I thought some of it would be true, especially her being buried alive.
ALSO, I'm crossing Ali off my "A" list, because if they're trying to make us think she's A then she's probably not "A."
ALSO, I truly hope Mona doesn't die. She's one of the best characters on the show, and probably the best actor on the show. She helps carry the show and I think it would be a HUGE mistake to kill her off. I really don't want Melissa to die either because I love her character, but killing Mona off would be detrimental to the show IMO.
ALSO, I'm crossing Ali off my "A" list, because if they're trying to make us think she's A then she's probably not "A."
ALSO, I truly hope Mona doesn't die. She's one of the best characters on the show, and probably the best actor on the show. She helps carry the show and I think it would be a HUGE mistake to kill her off. I really don't want Melissa to die either because I love her character, but killing Mona off would be detrimental to the show IMO.
-
- Master Gossiper
- Posts: 3702
- Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 4:32 pm
- Has thanked: 0
- Been thanked: 0
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
I feel like they've totally wasted Mike's character. They could be doing so much with his character, but they pretty much put him on the backburner. I mean he's dating Mona, plus he's been caught stealing multiple times, and allegedly busted that guy's window in who made up that story about Aria. They should totally show him being on the "A" team, plotting with Mona against Ali or the girls. The Montgomery family has a history of mental illness, they could play that up like Mike doesn't really know what's he doing or something. IDK. But, I feel like by adding all these new characters it's just makes things so much more complicated when they could be expanding on the characters they already had.xyz wrote:
ETA: I don't think they'll kill off paige or else I don't think they would have went through the trouble of showing her on a date..i hope its not mike, not bc I like his character but bc I think his character could be a good one they could build upon.I don't like tanner either but I think its part of her character to be annoying. I bet they'll kill off some random nobody knows or that has only been seen for like a second.
Like, what are they doing with Ezra. Are they done with him, I mean he's a fan favorite (as creepy as he is). Are they really going with the whole he was writing a book plot line? What about the part where he became crazy obsessive, or the theory that Jason gave him the 10k or 15k (Whatever it was) to find Ali. They should be revealing tiny gems like this as we go to give back to the fans.
I hope they bring Jason back for 5b too.
I feel like they could be giving us a lot more answers and still stretch the show out as long as possible. I love the show, but this last episode really disappointed unless it all somehow starts to make sense next week.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 2409
- Joined: Wed Apr 03, 2013 6:59 pm
- Has thanked: 1 time
- Been thanked: 6 times
- Contact:
Re: Pretty Little Liars - Theories and Spoilers - Part 2
I seriously hate how they keep bringing up Ravenswood. Literally no one will ever watch that so just drop it.